Otis State Forest pipeline protesters arrested and charged by State Police

More Info
By Wednesday, May 3 News  10 Comments

EdgeCast video by Ben Hillman

Sandisfield — Eighteen protesters, including a western Massachusetts selectman, were arrested Tuesday morning (May 2) in two separate locations half a mile apart after more than 50 determined demonstrators blocked access roads in the Otis State Forest, preventing Tennessee Gas Pipeline company’s personnel and equipment from cutting trees in preparation for the construction of a controversial pipeline extension.

The protest operation went like clockwork. The protesters arrived as early as 6:30 a.m. By 7 a.m. members of the Sugar Shack Alliance were holding signs and a banner that read, “Save Our Forest Save Our Water. Save Our Earth. Unite. Resist. Protect.”

Protesters gather at Access Road 3 to prevent Tennessee Gas workmen from entering Otis State Forest. Photo: Will Elwell

Protesters gather at Access Road 3 to prevent Tennessee Gas workmen from entering Otis State Forest. Photo: Will Elwell

They then began a protest march at Lower Spectacle Pond against the plans of Tennessee Gas, a subsidiary of energy giant Kinder Morgan, to clear almost 30 acres of publicly owned forest to make room for a natural gas pipeline expansion. Tuesday’s protest follows another one on Friday and yet another last July .

By 7:30 a.m., nine activists had secured a chain across Access Road 3, chanting “This is What Democracy Looks Like” and “We are Stopping Pipelines, Never Turning Back.”

Half an hour later, a dozen work vehicles, two State Police cruisers and two private security cars arrived. At 8:15 a.m., the people of the chain barricade said “No” when asked by the State Troopers to let the private security personnel report for work on Access Road 3.

Ron Coler, a selectman in the town of Ashfield and member of the Sugar Shack Alliance. Photo: Will Elwell

Ron Coler, a selectman in the town of Ashfield and member of the Sugar Shack Alliance. Photo: Will Elwell

By 11 a.m. the Sugar Shack’s media coordinators had sent out an email blast announcing that nine protesters, including Ashfield Selectman Ron Coler, had been handcuffed, arrested by State Police and brought to the county jail by the Berkshire County Sheriff and then on to Southern Berkshire District Court in Great Barrington for a magistrate’s hearing.

“They were charged with trespassing and disorderly conduct,” confirmed Dan Sheridan, assistant superintendent at the Berkshire County Sheriff’s Office, which booked them and brought them to Great Barrington. In all there were 18 people arrested, nine women and nine men, he said.

“The 18 protesters blocked two access roads and indicated that they wanted to be arrested,” State Police spokesman David Procopio said in a news release late Monday afternoon (May 1).

According to Procopio, protesters notified State Police beforehand that they would not comply with requests to disperse from the roads. After the protesters, in two groups of nine apiece, refused to comply with repeated requests to scatter, they were charged with trespassing. However, Procopio added, “All those arrested were respectful and peaceful.”

A State Trooper explains to protesters that they will be arrested if they deny access to Otis State Forest. Photo: Will Elwell

A State Trooper explains to protesters that they will be arrested if they deny access to Otis State Forest. Photo: Will Elwell

Will Elwell, one of the protesters at the scene, said his colleagues were arrested as a result of two separate resistance events in the forest. The first was what Elwell called a “hard blockade” with a metal chain stretched across the dirt road by protesters and locked across Access Road 3.

In addition, there was a soft blockade about half a mile away at Access Road 2, where protesters simply stood in the way of workers and equipment without a chain, Elwell said.

“The whole process was very orderly and State Police were very friendly and efficient,” Elwell said. “There were no conflicts of any sort. It was very well managed and very peaceful … police asked them to come forward and put handcuffs on them.”

A protester being put into a Berkshire County Sheriff's van. Photo: Will Elwell

A protester being put into a Berkshire County Sheriff’s van. Photo: Will Elwell

Procopio, the State Police spokesman, said the accused are free until next Monday, May 9, when they are scheduled to reappear at Southern Berkshire District Court.

Kinder Morgan’s project has been mired in legal entanglements. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) approved the project and gave the go-ahead for tree clearing and construction on April 12. Dubbed the Connecticut Expansion Project, the operation would extend the company’s existing natural gas pipeline infrastructure across three states – New York, Connecticut and Massachusetts – and see four miles of new underground pipeline. Both Massachusetts U.S. Senators Elizabeth Warren and Ed Markey, and U.S. Rep. Richard Neal (D-Springfield) challenged the FERC ruling and have asked the agency to revoke it, on the grounds that the agency did not have a quorum to adopt the ruling and furthermore that the market for natural gas had declined so much that the pipeline was unnecessary.

Lower Spectacle Pond from which millions of gallons would be drawn to flush out the gas pipeline. Photo: Will Elwell

Lower Spectacle Pond from which millions of gallons would be drawn to flush out the gas pipeline. Photo: Will Elwell

Expanding the existing pipeline corridor in Otis State Forest requires clearing of dozens of acres of forest that is now owned by the state, which purchased it for conservation and put it into protection under the Department of Conservation Resources (DCR) and the state constitution.

Theoretically, the Otis State Forest is protected under Article 97 of the Massachusetts constitution, and was adopted in 1972. The article says “the people shall have a right to clean air and water … and the natural scenic, historic, and esthetic qualities of their environment,” with the fulfillment of these rights to be carried out through state parkland acquisition and conservation.

Handcuffed protesters being led to sheriff's vans for transport to the Berkshire County Jail.

Handcuffed protesters being led to sheriff’s vans for transport to the Berkshire County Jail.

The Otis State Forest protesters base some of their opposition to the pipeline project on Article 97. In addition, the dissenters object to the expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure on the grounds that it contributes to climate change.

“We are committed to using all the non-violent tactics at our disposal in our ongoing opposition to the Connecticut Expansion Project in Otis State Forest,” said Irvine Sobleman, a Sugar Shack member from Northampton who participated in today’s action.

“In the face of ongoing climate change, it is crystal clear that [our] responsibility [to protect the earth] requires us to reject all fossil fuel infrastructure construction, no matter how small or large the project may be.”

State Police have released the names of those arrested:

John K. Cohen, 79, of Northampton

Ronald R. Coler, 61, of Ashfield

Joan L. Levy, 64, of Pelham

Rema Loeb, 84, of Plainfield

Micky Mckinley, 72, of Montague

Asaph Murfin, 74, of Leverett

Harriet Nestel, 78, of Athol

James Perkins, 78, of Leverett

Amy Pulley, 61, of Cummington

Diane Sibley, 68, of Ashfield

Vivienne L. Simon, 66, of Northampton

Stephen J. Stoia, 69, of Northfield

Susan L. Triolo, 67, of Sunderland

Benjamin James Vanarnam, 30, of Easthampton

Lydia Vernon-Jones, 68, of Amherst

Russell Vernon-Jones, 70, of Amherst

Martin H. Urbel, 74, of Northampton

Kevin A. Young, 32, of Northampton

The first nine protesters to be arrested for blocking the road to Otis State Forest.

The first nine protesters to be arrested for blocking the road to Otis State Forest. Photo: Ben Hillman

Return Home

10 Comments   Add Comment

  1. RAC says:

    “Tin Soldiers and Nixon coming” meets L.L. Bean.

  2. AnnaMarie Russo says:

    Much love and respect to the people who organized the Spectacle Pond action against the tree cutting, the pipeline, and the fossil fuel-industrial complex – to the ones who get arrested, and the ones who stood by them giving support. Resist!

  3. sian says:

    Thank you to all participants for standing up, and to the State Police for fair behaviour. Hail galant Resisters.

  4. John says:

    It never ends well when you defy law enforcement. Most of these folks are in the sunset of their life and have little to loose now having arrest records. Interesting too that most of these folks are not local to the Forrest.
    We all want to protect our environment. In truth, it is just amazing to see just how energy efficient homes, cars, appliances have become over the years. That trend will continue as economics are the real propellant of those efforts.
    If these folks really want to make meaningful change, a focus on population control can make a world of difference. The notion of having more than 2 children is a real driver to increased consumption of natural resources.

    1. Judy Barry says:

      It NEVER ENDS WELL? REALLY? It NEVER ENDS WELL WHEN YOU DEFY LAW ENFORCEMENT. 1942, Nazi Germany, how many people defied law enforcement to hide jewish children (and adults) from law enforcement? 1965- colored people to the back of the bus…..I could keep going on and on, but why waste my time-cement head

      1. John says:

        Judy Barry,
        Almost 60 years ago, my parents taught me that calling someone names was inappropriate, and wrong…
        I do hope that the next time you might be pulled over for speeding, that when asked for your license and registration, that you do not choose to defy the law. It could be a long night behind bars…
        Kind Regards

      2. Patrick Fennell says:

        Then why are you and your democrat friends continuing to re-elect Richie Neal, Ed Markey and local pols who have taken thousands of dollars from lobbyists. lawyers, contractors and oil companies. Look at their donor lists and you will be amazed at how much money our rookie state senator took from people who want the pipeline. Follow the money.

  5. Joseph Method says:

    Well done!

  6. Judy Barry says:

    I just did

  7. Den says:

    For the sake of the mental health of the now defendants, I do hope they are able to get the help they need. Fortunately, the list will keep growing of people who will be denied gun ownership due to their mental instability. Thank you.

What's your opinion?

We welcome your comments and appreciate your respect for others. We kindly ask you to keep your comments as civil and focused as possible. If this is your first time leaving a comment on our website we will send you an email confirmation to validate your identity.

Lyme disease: ‘Public health time bomb’ in the Berkshires environment

Thursday, Apr 19 - In her book, 'Lyme: The First Epidemic of Climate Change,' Mary Beth Pfeiffer presents evidence from all viewpoints, but her narrative sides with those who distrust the Lyme disease tests, seek more expansive – and expensive -- therapies, and believe Lyme is a tragic long-term problem for thousands of victims. She argues government underfunding of Lyme research is a scandal and current treatment flawed.