Neighbors of O’Brien waste business decry ‘industrial siege’ on Blue Hill Road

More Info
By Tuesday, Dec 12 News  7 Comments
Terry Cowgill
The Great Barrington Selectboard ponders the troubling situation in the Blue Hill neighborhood Monday night. From left, Town Manager Jennifer Tabakin, Selectboard Chair Sean Stanton, Steve Bannon, Ed Abrahams and Bill Cooke.

Editor’s note: This article has been corrected to reflect O’Brien’s holdings. GJO LLC does not own Roger Trucking. It is owned by RWB Services LLC.

Great Barrington — A loud business that’s violating the law and out of character with a residential neighborhood. Neighbors who are fed up with inaction and a selectboard at wit’s end with an unresponsive business owner.

Just another day in Town Hall, you say? Not quite. Half a dozen residents of the Blue Hill Road neighborhood, which is set off to the east of Stockbridge Road (Route 7) came to the Great Barrington Selectboard meeting Monday night (Dec. 11) to complain and sometimes vent about a heavy-equipment business whose vehicles roar up and down Blue Hill and Roger roads at all hours of the day – and night – and who seems to be ignoring a cease-and-desist order from building inspector and zoning enforcement officer Edwin May.

An aerial view of the O’Brien property at 11 Roger Rd.

“The citizens of the neighborhood need to band together and start a revolt in order to make things better,” said Dr. John Wojcik, who lives at 1 Roger Rd. “He runs stop signs and speeds along. There are dozens of trucks from Lee. Blue Hill Road is their favorite freeway.”

See video below of Dr. John Wojcik complaining to the selectboard:

“He” is Gary J. O’Brien, whose company, GJO LLC, operates various businesses including Irish Trucking and O’Brien Landscaping. The latter is a waste hauling and recycling company.

According to town manager Jennifer Tabakin, O’Brien’s Great Barrington operations, while located in a residential zone, predate the town’s adoption of zoning regulations in the 1930s, so they are considered pre-existing nonconforming uses.

Trucks were visible Monday afternoon through the trees, though there appeared to be no activity. Photo: Terry Cowgill

Nevertheless, O’Brien has pushed the envelope and has been issued multiple cease-and-desist orders in the last six years. On June 23, 2011, May issued O’Brien an order to immediately cease using the property as a landscaper’s yard because he was only permitted to use it as a tree farm. If he wanted to use it as a landscaper’s yard, he would have to apply for a special permit from the zoning board of appeals. The property had been found to be in violation three times in seven months.

The most recent order, dated Nov. 22, can seen by clicking here. It cites “multiple complaints” over the past four months about trucks “rumbling up Blue Hill Road, dumping materials and heavy equipment at early morning hours.” The order demands that O’Brien cease the illegal activity immediately.

May said O’Brien’s actions exceed the sort permitted on a property whose use is nonconforming. Furthermore, O’Brien’s operations are a violation of the 1996 agreement for judgement in the case of the Town of Great Barrington v. Leamon Roger, which May had also cited in previous orders. That judgement ordered O’Brien to halt all transfer-station activities.

May’s site visit of Aug. 22 revealed waste dumping and the expansion of a parking lot without a site-plan review required by the town’s zoning bylaws. May ordered O’Brien to file for a site-plan review with the planning board.

Exacerbating the matter is that, as of Monday night’s selectboard meeting, O’Brien had not responded to May’s order, leaving the board scratching its collective heads about what step to take next.

Paul Jones. Photo: Terry Cowgill

If O’Brien disagrees with May’s order, then he has the right to appeal it to the zoning board of appeals, which he did when confronted with another order several years ago. But, so far, he has not acknowledged the order, nor has he indicated whether he intends to contest it.

The complexity and uncertainty of the process left many residents wondering if the town was taking their complaints (and May’s order) seriously. Some said that, in the past, they had called the police when they heard the rumblings and excessive noise. Sometimes the police were responsive but, on other occasions, they were not.

“They don’t care or they don’t want to get involved,” said Paul Jones, who said his father was a longtime Great Barrington police officer and a former acting chief. He said police have responded to the scene after complaints, watched O’Brien’s trucks run the stop sign at the bottom of Roger Road and done nothing. But mostly he was vexed that the quality of his life has been reduced greatly by the activity.

“I’m talking 30-ton trucks when they’re full going up and down that hill, shaking houses, shaking foundations,” Jones said, the exasperation evident in his voice. “The noise is inescapable. This has turned into an industrial siege.”

See video below of Paul Jones and Dr. Ruby Chang complaining and the selectboard deliberating over the matter:

Dr. Ruby Chang, a pediatrician and Wojcik’s wife, was most concerned about matters of public health–diesel exhaust and the effect it has on the human body.

“The citizens in and around my neighborhood are not being heard,” said Chang, who has lived at 1 Roger Rd. for five years and also sits of the town’s board of health. “I don’t know how long it’s going to take before these people who have lived there for 30 or 40 years to get lung cancer.”

Dr. Ruby Chang. Photo: Terry Cowgill

Since the matter came up during the public-comment portion of the meeting and was not on the agenda, the board appeared unprepared to talk about it in great detail.

Tabakin said the ZBA could make the final determination but selectboard Chairman Sean Stanton wondered how the matter could come before the ZBA if O’Brien simply ignored May’s order and did not appeal it. Tabakin was unsure whether the selectboard could appeal directly to the ZBA for a ruling, though she said the board could vote to ask the ZBA to put the matter on its agenda.

Fairview Terrace resident Roger Belanger, who submitted a letter of complaint to the board, said of the cease-and-desist order: “It must have been very weak because the noise continues. I just don’t understand why the board doesn’t act or they’re afraid to act.”

See video below of Fairview Terrace resident Roger Belanger speaking and the selectboard and town manager Jennifer Tabakin responding:

“The problem with enforcement is the previous ZBA ruling did not prohibit the trucks from being on the road,” Tabakin explained. “They established that it was a permissible nonconforming use.”

Stanton wanted to know if O’Brien would face a daily fine for operating in defiance of May’s order. No one seemed to know, but planning board member Jonathan Hankin said zoning violations are subject to fines, though he did not know if one had been levied against O’Brien.

The intersection of Blue Hill Road and Fairview Terrace, where a residential neighborhood sits only a stone’s throw away from an industrial site. Photo: Terry Cowgill

“Anyone violating zoning can be fined $300 a day,” Hankin said. He added that, if O’Brien remained unresponsive, then the board should ask May what the next step should be.

May said in 2011 that, if O’Brien failed to stop his operations, daily fines will accrue at a rate of $25 for the first day, $50 for the second, $100 for the third and $200 for each subsequent day he is in contempt of the order. Failing that, the next step is to take O’Brien to court.

At that time, O’Brien’s lawyer, Edward “Buddy” McCormick, contended that the 1996 Superior Court judgment allowed certain limited commercial activities on the property, permission that he insisted was passed on to O’Brien when he purchased the parcel in 2010.

Michael Andelman. Photo: Terry Cowgill

It is clear that something needs to be done soon, if for no other reason than to protect the sanity and well-being of nearby residents. In addition to the trucks and the transfer station activities, there are reports of race cars gunning their engines on the O’Brien property on the weekends.

“The excessive truck noises start as early as 4 a.m. and run until as late as 8 p.m., said Michael Andelman, who lives at 17 Blue Hill Rd. “The slam of heavy metal, possibly tailgates of dump trucks start sometimes earlier than 4 a.m. and banging loudly throughout the day.”

Andelman, who had filed a formal complaint to the town, further described “the outrageous noise of what I think is a race car starting, idling and revving, sounding like explosions intermittently any day of the week.” The noise is made worse by the elevation of the O’Brien property which sits on the side of a hill and overlooks the aggrieved residential neighbors to the west.

See video below of Blue Hill Road resident Michael Andelman’s plea to the selectboard:

“He has four racing cars up there. We hear them on the weekends,” added Wojcik. “Whenever I call the police department, I get laughed at.”

In addition, a house at the bottom of the driveway that is part of the O’Brien property is boarded up and has been unoccupied since at least 2011, Jones said. That raises questions, he added, about whether the property can continue to operate as a nonconforming use if it has a “residence with no residents.”

The driveway leading up the hill to the O’Brien property. Photo: Terry Cowgill

“The fact that you’re getting laughed at when you call the police department needs to be dealt with,” Stanton replied. “The fact that the house is condemned needs to be dealt with.”

Selectman Steve Bannon noted that the board was “caught between a rock and hard place.” He suggested the board direct Tabakin to investigate the matter and return with a preliminary report at the board’s next scheduled meeting on Monday, Dec. 18, at 7 p.m. The motion passed unanimously.


Return Home

7 Comments   Add Comment

  1. Steve Farina says:

    We should shut down ALL the businesses in town. On one side we have an airport that was preexisting the town zoning laws and on the other we have this. Downtown we have train tracks that rumble all day, shaking the homes and buildings as they travel, often carrying trash and construction debris. Additionally there is the incessant truck noise at all hours of day and night as trash gets removed, recyclables get dumped in large quantities with the sound of breaking glass echoing off the buildings.
    Add to that the delivery and supply trucks showing up at ungodly hours of the morning…all of these often spewing diesel exhaust. Downtown air quality is horrific.
    When I moved into the center of town last year I had no idea these things would happen…rip up the train tracks, shut down the restaurants, let the trash pile up, keep the store shelves bare, and make sure another couple hundred people lose their jobs (last I knew the Obrien businesses employed somewhere around 60 people – it may be even more now).
    This would have the added benefit of solving the town’s parking issue.

    It doesn’t matter what was preexisting – or when I knowingly moved here, whether any of the businesses in town experience growth, if other people are employed or not…it is all about me, and if we could just make all of this go away:

    Just think how quiet and peaceful life would be

    1. Pete says:

      Do we need laws for someone to be a good neighbor? In this case, apparently so as there seems to be total disregard for anyone living in that area. If the business was cited for illegal activity they need to suffer the consequences. The Board and police need to step up to the plate and do their job.

    2. Anonymous says:

      I’m always interested in hearing different perspectives as long as it’s done in a respectful and constructive manner.

      One theme I’ve noticed in general since moving here to Berkshires is that many people/businesses/groups often simply do whatever it is they want – with little or no regard/thought to rules/regulations, those around them, or what is “right.” They just charge forward, passively daring anyone to stop them.

      I’ve researched this particular matter out of curiosity (with the help of articles like this) and from what I can tell this was a BIG problem waiting to happen dating back, at least, to the property sale to O’Brien in 2010 (?) – To think that you’re going to relocate your construction/landscaping operations into a fully residentially zoned neighborhood and scale the size of the business over time and not get resistance from the local residents is a laughable notion, and ultimately a bad business decision. Especially when there are many areas in and near GB that are zoned for exactly this type of work.

      The fact that the Town of GB appears to have put in the most minimal effort it can to address the matter and provides barely any support to a growing number of increasingly frustrated area residents on this matter of complaint that dates back nearly 7 years to 2011 (one year after O’Brien bought) shows the impotence and incompetence of elected Town “leaders.” The Town suggests it isn’t taking sides, but by their actions (and inactions) it cannot be argued that they are taking any side but that of O’Brien – who through his inaction and lack of response to C&D orders and other inquiries clearly snubs his nose at both the Town and neighborhood residents, perhaps while he attempts to be more quiet with his operations for a time, only to ramp back up again later.

      Again out of curiosity, I made visits to this neighborhood recently to see for myself. I came in early morning (5am), end of day (5pm) and several visits in between. I was there for at least an hour each visit. It is as the residents say.

      A parade of large, heavy dump trucks, and other smaller commercial trucks come down Roger Rd and Blue Hill Rd at a time of day that landscapers/contractors get started each day, but not one that a residential area does (by all the dark, unlit houses). This parade of trucks from O’Brien’s operation only comes after the parade of personal trucks/vehicles goes up the road as workers show up for work. This flow of trucks and other vehicles appears to be consistent and throughout the day as daily work operations continue. There are also other vehicles such as vendors that service O’Brien operations with repairs and tools so those vehicles use the residential neighborhood too.

      If this can happen in a fully residential zoned area, it can happen in any. Even on The Hill in GB?

      I have nothing against O’Brien, or him/anyone trying to run a business and make a living. He’s simply doing it at the expense of GB residents. And in my opinion made a bad business decision to setup his operations at that location.

      GB Town officials should be embarrassed at their ineffectiveness to address a matter with binding and conclusive decision such that the can continues to be kicked down the road, and so nearly 7 years later, the same issue exists. You should be ashamed. Be leaders, and do your job – before someone else does it for you.

      I feel for the area residents in this neighborhood. I’m sure it’s been a challenging (or worse at times) 7 years. Try new approaches to solving this matter, and I bet before long you can resolve it.

      1. Bob Fedell says:

        Just to add a bit to your information… Leamon Roger and his family started his refuse business at the location in 1945, before zoning was in place (much like the airport). Leamon is now long dead, but his grandson Robert Brownson still owns and runs the business, not Gary O’Brien. Rob moved the business years ago to an industrial zoned are and it is no longer a source of noise for the neighbors.

        The houses where the doctors live were built around 2004, over 60+ years after the commercial business started legally. Those houses were built knowing that a commercial business was in existence there. And with few exceptions, the people who now live in the extended area moved there knowing the commercial business was there too.

  2. Shawn says:

    We could boycott their businesses…ie. choose another business.

  3. Jeffrey Smith says:

    Wasn’t this why they fired O’Donnell for his failure to act on this? What’s she been doing the last five years.

  4. Michael Wise says:

    The town of Breat Barrington adopted a zoning bylaw at the town meeting in March 1932. The zoning bylaw has become more complex over the years since then, and there have been many refinements of detail, but the basic scheme has not changed that much. The town clerk has a file, which is available for consultation, that includes the bylaws and zoning maps as they have evolved. (I am a member of the town Zoning Board of Appeals; I dug out this history in connection with my first proceeding at the ZBA seven year ago).

What's your opinion?

We welcome your comments and appreciate your respect for others. We kindly ask you to keep your comments as civil and focused as possible. If this is your first time leaving a comment on our website we will send you an email confirmation to validate your identity.

Lea Zavattaro, 102, of Lee

Friday, Feb 23 - Mrs. Zavattaro enjoyed cooking and spending time with her friends and family over a cup of coffee.