EPA insists off-site disposal of PCB sediment is preferred option

More Info
By Sunday, May 29 News  1 Comment
Heather Bellow
It is not safe to eat fish or wildlife taken from the Housatonic River because of PCB contamination, as this sign in Sheffield warns.

Boston — A status update issued Wednesday (May 25) by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on the General Electric’s Company’s cleanup of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) from the Housatonic River appears to have been distributed to clear up “incorrect” information in a “recent [newspaper] article.”

In a prepared statement EPA Public Affairs Specialist Kelsey O’Neil wrote that the article “mistakenly stated that GE was originally asked to remove almost three times the amount of soil it is responsible for today, but that EPA had compromised with GE to allow for a speedier cleanup.”

That wasn’t all that needed clearing up, O’Neil noted: “GE’s Corrective Measures Study evaluated alternatives for addressing the sediments and floodplains. That set of alternatives did include one alternative (out of eight, including a no action alternative) with three times the volume of material than proposed…EPA never asked/directed or indicated this was EPA’s preferred remedy in any document…”

A court-ordered Consent Decree is forcing GE to clean up the “Rest of River” from south of the company’s former electric transformer plant in Pittsfield to the Connecticut border. PCB-laced industrial waste was for decades discharged into the river from the plant and still continues to seep into it, polluting its sediment.

While some earlier EPA documents say PCBs are “probably human carcinogens,” the EPA now says “PCBs have been demonstrated to cause a wide variety of adverse health effects, including cancer. PCBs also cause serious non-cancer health effects in animals, including effects on the immune system, reproductive system, nervous system, endocrine system and other organs. Studies in humans provide supportive evidence for potential carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic effects of PCBs.”

In September 2015 the EPA issued its intended final cleanup decision, and GE entered dispute resolution in which it argued with the EPA over several of its decisions, including shipping the PCB sludge out of state to a facility that can handle it. Instead, GE is considering dumping the waste into three proposed Berkshire county sites.

Nothing appears to have changed with this reminder from O’Neil. Both the EPA and GE’s positions are “currently under review by an EPA decision maker,” she wrote.  Beyond that, she added, “the next formal step in the Consent Decree is for EPA to issue a final cleanup decision.”

O’Neil wanted to further “correct any confusion regarding EPA’s position on disposal of PCBs,” something Berkshire County residents are keeping a close eye on.

“To reiterate,” she wrote, “the EPA’s recommendation for disposal of excavated material is for off-site disposal at an existing licensed facility. EPA’s recommendation has been consistent in all its proposals.” There are no such licensed disposal facilities in Massachusetts.

The EPA has proposed a “combination of different types of remediation, including specifically: excavation and backfill of an estimated 990,000 cubic yards of PCB-contaminated material;

Containment/capping of remaining PCBs; Monitored Natural Recovery where appropriate; use of a sediment amendment, such as activated carbon, to reduce mobility of PCBs.”

EPA Community Involvement Coordinator Jim Murphy told the Edge that O’Neil’s dispatch was “just a status update.”

For further information, check the EPA website at https://www.epa.gov/ge-housatonic

Return Home

One Comment   Add Comment

  1. Sage Radachowsky says:

    Monsanto made the PCBs that have made the Housatonic into a ghost river.

What's your opinion?

We welcome your comments and appreciate your respect for others. We kindly ask you to keep your comments as civil and focused as possible. If this is your first time leaving a comment on our website we will send you an email confirmation to validate your identity.

Welcome to Real Estate Friday!

Friday, Apr 20 - Lots of new listings this week for your weekend perusing. Plus a report on the health of the real estate market from a well-placed professional.

Lyme disease: ‘Public health time bomb’ in the Berkshires environment

Thursday, Apr 19 - In her book, 'Lyme: The First Epidemic of Climate Change,' Mary Beth Pfeiffer presents evidence from all viewpoints, but her narrative sides with those who distrust the Lyme disease tests, seek more expansive – and expensive -- therapies, and believe Lyme is a tragic long-term problem for thousands of victims. She argues government underfunding of Lyme research is a scandal and current treatment flawed.