• Local
  • Pittsfield, MA
  • more weather >
David Scribner
Robin Helfand of Robin's Candy Shop, with 'foliage' for the dead shadblow sapling planted in the spring in front of her Main Street store. The tree was one of a diverse selection of 81 young trees that replaced the 35-year-old flowering Bradford pears.

Dying Main Street trees to be replaced

More Info
By Tuesday, Jul 12, 2016 News 8

Great Barrington – When Robin Helfand, the owner at Robin’s Candy Shop at 288 Main St. discovered that the newly planted shadblow sapling in front of her store had died, she did not hesitate or wait for the town – or state high department or whoever was responsible for the plantings – to replace the tree. She took it upon herself to hang her own foliage on the barren branches in front of her store. It was the least she could do – and it wasn’t the first time she had acted to salvage the appearance of life on Main Street. Last fall, she had Ward’s Nursery donate a small hemlock for the empty tree pit. During the winter, it was the only tree left along the new sidewalks in downtown Great Barrington, after the 35-year-old Bradford pear trees had been removed during the Main Street Reconstruction Project.

Lily Abrahams affixes Robin Helfand's 'leaves' to sapling on the sidewalk in front of Robin's Candy.

Lily Abrahams affixes Robin Helfand’s ‘leaves’ to sapling on the sidewalk in front of Robin’s Candy.

Although many residents were heartbroken over the loss of Main Street’s Bradford Pear trees, whose springtime blooms and summer leaves had created a shaded sidewalk allées, downtown was expected to have been brought back to life with the planting of 81 new young trees this spring. The plantings were to be the final element in the $5.4 million rebuilding of the Main Street corridor.

Unfortunately, some of the trees are now dead or dying, with four or five shadblows confirmed as unsalvageable, according to arborist Tom Ingersoll.

“It’s a real disappointment to me that the few final items [in the renovation] are not being attended to with urgency,” Helfand told the Edge, referring to promises she was given by state workers and town officials that the trees’ replacement could take up to a year.

Ingersoll, a Massachusetts Certified Arborist working as a consultant for MassDOT throughout the renovation, confirmed to the Edge that, as per contract, the trees would be replaced within a year. He added the possibility of the removal and replacement as early as the coming fall season.

Still, Helfand is frustrated. “Now that trees that are dead or dying have been identified, it would be better if they were removed and the tree pits left empty instead of having dead trees there.”

Acknowledging the loss, Town Manager Jennifer Tabakin told the Selectboard, however, that there was a “delay in getting all the different types of plants [trees] for lack of availability.” She said the town was working on maintaining what was planted and on getting those replacements.

A dying shadblow in front of Fuel Coffeeshop.

A dying shadblow in front of Fuel Coffeeshop.

Helfand suggested a possible town-organized movement to remove the trees if going through the state would take too long. “I want customers seeing as appealing a street space as possible.” Several merchants, including Helfand, have come together and agreed to privately fund the removal of the trees if necessary.

But Ingersoll still has not given up on the recently planted trees. “It’s hard to tell if they are dying or growing back,” he told the Edge. “This is still a work in progress, it changes day to day, and I’m going through there constantly and checking. I’ve seen more trees stabilize than I have seen get worse.” Original estimates of 14 dead or dying trees, he added, have dropped down to 4 or 5 confirmed dead trees. “If we had tried to make that decision two weeks ago we would have ripped out 14 trees.”

Shadblows are an early-blooming tree, and Ingersoll attributed their health problems to a heavy freeze on the night of April 4th while they were still in the nursery. “It destroyed flower buds and leaf buds or at best deformed them,” he said.

For now, the town is urging pedestrians to stay out of the planting pits surrounding the trees, as compacting the soil can harm the roots. Since annual precipitation this year is 4 or 5 inches below average, the emphasis is on watering the trees, which will be done by state workers.

More by »

8 Comments   Add Comment

  1. Bob says:

    Wait a minute here. So they are talking about the new trees that WERE just planted? There are ones that are already dead?! And they won’t replace them until the fall?!

  2. lolacola says:

    yes typical for this project…
    Let’s put up sharp granite curbs to damage tires, planting beds, that a lot of them are filled with just weeds, and no one seems to
    take care of them. How are people supposed to avoid the tree beds when the parking space is inches away, and when someone
    gets out of the car on the passenger side you can’t help but step on them. Why couldn’t they just plant common trees that do well in this area instead of all these “never heard of tree varieties”.

  3. Alix, GB says:

    Shadblow is a graceful tree in some settings (I have one), but it is definitely not a shade tree and does not grow very large. Its blooms are not prepossessing. I don’t know what the planners/designers are thinking.

  4. Michael Wise says:

    One of the principles the planners followed was, no monoculture. Another was to plant varieties that are “local” and/or that will do well here. The Tree Committee (I’m a member) went over the choices in great detail during the design stage (the marked-up list of choices in my file dates from five years ago!). There are about ten different varieties, some which will become tall, some which will be lower or mid-sized. Among them are flowering cherry and pear, oak, maple, elm, yellowood, hornbeam, katsura, and these shads. The shads seem to be struggling, but the arborist who is working for the town on this project (and who is quoted in the article) advises patience. If it turns out that they have to be replaced, it would make more sense to replant in the fall, or spring, than in the summer.

  5. Shawn says:

    Only 6% of the trees have died. Calm down, people.

    1. Cathy Fracasse says:

      Thanks for that – the constant outcry is a bit tiresome. Transplanted trees have a certain failure rate. This is not the end of the world.

  6. Art says:

    We all mourned the loss of the Bradford Pear trees though we also understood that we had virtually no choice in replacing them. The new trees that died will be replaced within a few months. Come on people. Even if available, do you really want to plant new street trees during the heat of the summer? I kind of think it’s time to move on. There are plenty of other legitimate issues around us to be angry about. Kudos to Robin for finding the humor in It and being proactive, by the way.

  7. Karen Shreefter says:

    As landscape designer I was sorely disappointed when I attended a meeting about the discussion of trees to be planted to replace the Bradford pears. I told some members of the tree committee what Michael Dirr, the foremost tree expert in the country, had suggested as trees to replace The Bradford pears. Those suggestions were ignored. I expressed my concern that Shadblow, which is not drought tolerant and usually is found at the edge of forests where they don’t get full sun all day, would not survive. Alas they are not surviving and so much money has been wasted.

What's your opinion?

We welcome your comments and appreciate your respect for others. We kindly ask you to keep your comments as civil and focused as possible. If this is your first time leaving a comment on our website we will send you an email confirmation to validate your identity.