The democracy of dreams

More Info
By Monday, Jan 16 Viewpoints  1 Comment

The recorded life of human imagination glows with extraordinary accomplishment. All the fabulists — from Homer, Aesop and the Grimms to H.G.Wells, Kafka, and Bernard Malamud —writers, poets and playwrights have enriched us over the centuries with the far-fetched products of their fevered imaginative minds. Their world of make-believe and fiction has colored our more usually concrete and problem-solving lives with images, stories, possibilities, creations that far exceed our usual mental diets.

From the adventures of Odysseus to the lives of the dybbuks, from the authors of Tarzan and Captain Kirk, from science-fiction writers who live in the future, from all the fictionalists who live in their made-up universes, persons with a rare gift for creative ideas and stories have pointed to a world far beyond the usual, the observable, the here-and-now, the consensually agreed-upon “real world.” The world’s literature, and perhaps all the world’s arts, have grown from the minds and capacities of a rare breed of imaginalists.

These special people with vivid imaginations and a capacity to share their fancies with the rest of us deserve our gratitude. While they have often been condemned, even punished for their crazy tales that challenge our more “normal” ways of thinking, their capacity to stretch the bounds of the everyday may border on madness or show itself as skillful craft. They weave their ideas into our more mundane surfaces and often help us live a richer life for their efforts.

The capacity for make-believe is so highly valued that in many a kindergarten class, exercises in imagination form part of the daily fare for many of our children. Teachers encourage little ones to take a chance, to draw outside the lines, to create, to make up, to pretend. For some children, this is a great pleasure, the joy of permitted freedom — but for some, a torment. I remember I used to need to be able to draw inside the lines. I used to love to “line up in size places.” The safety and certitude of the rules was wonderful for me. At 40, I was able finally to “draw outside the lines,” as I became a painter of make-believe. Many people need time to be able to pretend. As a child in an immigrant Jewish European family, the daily dose of shared chaos within the Holocaust experience was “creative,” chancy, wild enough for me. A bit of predictability was for me a heaven of sorts.

So, we are all different when in comes to the capacity for creating and for appreciating make-believe. Some children are terrified of dolls, puppets, and masks. Others revel in stretching reality. It is amazing to realize how much we all share the capacity for imagination. I would only point to one area in life to confirm this assertion: each night, every night, we dream. From earliest brain development (presumably in most all mammals) to the mind as it engages with dying — i.e., for the whole of one’s life — dreams fill our sleeping minds.

And dreams are a most vivid demonstration of the mind at work and/or play in making things up, in creating, in storytelling, in make-believe. In dreaming, we create, participate and live in a make-believe world — for a time. All of us. No matter one’s capacity for imagination in waking life, in dreams, there is a democracy of imagination– some more, some less, but all of us busy through the night and sleep making up dreams.

This world of imagination is an amazing one — with rules and requirements all its own.

Why and how come remain mysteries. But we all have the capacity and all have extensive experience living imaginary experiences in our sleeping minds. This fact is especially important for persons who experience themselves as barren or depressed, and for those who have been criticized or have criticized themselves for a lack of creative spark. Such persons need to become aware of their dreaming minds. They have been making up stories since infancy. This imagining mind belongs to and is a rich capacity for everyone. Everyone, in every clime, in every era in history.

The only conditions are that one is asleep, that no one but the dreamer is watching, that the internal and external critics are inactivated, that no one is keeping score or giving grades. In such conditions, one is free to make up all manner of things. No charge. No fee. Just pure freedom, in the deep privacy of sleep. Watch what happens tonight or tomorrow night or this week.

Notice your imagining minds at play. Not all fun. Some of it silly or dark or scary. But your personal and private imagination nonetheless.


Return Home

One Comment   Add Comment

  1. Bob Feuer says:

    Yea, Paul!

What's your opinion?

We welcome your comments and appreciate your respect for others. We kindly ask you to keep your comments as civil and focused as possible. If this is your first time leaving a comment on our website we will send you an email confirmation to validate your identity.


Friday, May 26 - These tax cuts only benefit wealthy households. The bottom 80 percent of households get roughly zero benefit from either of these tax cuts, according to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center.

Criticism of Trump is inconsistent

Wednesday, May 24 - In his letter to the editor, Patrick Fennell writes: "Berkshire County has three Registry of Deeds offices; Suffolk County with a population 780,000 has but one and no one questions the waste."

LEONARD QUART: On writing a eulogy

Tuesday, May 23 - I try to evoke my friends in a way that makes them come alive, always understanding by choice and by ultimate lack of knowledge -- that I have merely scratched the surface.

Trinity Church’s brave stance on immigrants

Monday, May 22 - In his letter to the edtior, Daniel Klein writes: "The time has come for all of us to take the next courageous step of declaring our houses of worship in Great Barrington as safe havens."

We are one with the stranger among us

Sunday, May 21 - In his letter to the editor, Rabbi Neil Hirsch writes: “The times we are living in are calling to us, inviting us to remember our roots, and to find compassion in the kinship of shared immigrant narratives.”

Signs of the times

Friday, May 19 - “Our understanding of the scriptures, scriptures we consider inspired by God, tells us to welcome all people in all circumstances as fellow human beings.” -- The Rev. Michael Tuck, rector of Trinity Church in Lenox